Advertisement

Liquid Chromatography versus Gas Chromatography

By Susha Cheriyedath, MSc

Chromatography is a proven method used to separate complex samples into their constituents, and it is undisputedly the most important procedure for isolating and purifying chemicals. It is classified into two types based on the physical state of the mobile phase used – liquid chromatography (LC) and gas chromatography (GC).

Chromatography includes a series of procedures that have in common the separation of components of a mixture by a series of equilibrium operations that result in the separation of the entities as a result of their partitioning between two distinct phases – one stationary with a large surface and other moving which is in contact with the first.

Liquid chromatography

LC is one of the most popular separation techniques used in labs for the separation of a sample mixture on the basis of the interactions between the individual molecules in the sample with the aforementioned stationary and mobile phases. It can be carried out either in a column or on a sheet with a liquid mobile phase and solid support as the stationary phase.

The mobile phase travels down the stationary phase bringing along the components of the sample separated during chromatography. In LC, the interaction between sample molecules and the chromatography medium may be based on several factors such as size, charge, affinity binding, or hydrophobicity.

An advanced form of the LC technique that uses high pressure to force sample through the column is called high performance liquid chromatography or high pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC). It is currently the most extensively used method of quantitative analysis in pharmaceutical analysis laboratories and in the pharmaceutical industry as a whole.

Gas chromatography

GC is another widely used chromatography technique. Here the mobile phase is usually an inert gas such as helium or argon (also known as the carrier gas), while the technique itself is performed in a capillary or packed column made up of inert materials. Even though packed columns are cheaper and user-friendly, capillary columns provide greater resolution and are relatively expensive.

The stationary phase is either a granular solid (i.e. gas-solid chromatography), or a granular solid coated with a thin film of nonvolatile liquid (i.e. gas-liquid chromatography). A majority of analytical gas chromatographs employ capillary columns, where the stationary phase directly coats the walls of a tube with a small diameter.

GC is usually used to separate vaporizable or volatile compounds and test their purity. It is also used to quantify the different components in a mixture. Although volatility of a sample is a prerequisite for GC analysis, the modification of the functional group of a certain molecule by a process known as derivatization enables the analysis of compounds that otherwise could not be easily monitored by GC.

In GC, the separation of components of a mixture depends on the length and temperature of the column, as well as on the flow rate of the carrier gas. These conditions must be optimized for a particular analysis.

In both GC and LC, detection of the individual components in the sample can be carried out by several methods. The most common and sensitive detection method is mass spectrometry, which identifies compounds based on the atomic sample organization of the molecules and their charge state.

Differences between of LC and GC

The key differences between liquid and gas chromatography are tabulated below.

Liquid Chromatography

Gas Chromatography

Mobile phase is a liquid

Mobile phase is a gas

Separation is based on interaction of solute with the chromatography medium

Separation is primarily based on the boiling points of solute molecules

Can be performed in a sheet or a column

Can be carried out only in a column

Can be used to separate any soluble compound, e.g. amino acids, proteins, drugs, nucleic acids, lipids, antioxidants, carbohydrates, and natural and artificial polymers

Can be applied in the separation of volatile compounds and gaseous mixtures

Usually carried out at room temperature so heat-sensitive compounds can be safely analyzed using the technique

Performed at higher temperatures so thermally labile substances might get denatured

Solute retention here is based on the interaction of solutes with the mobile and stationary phases so it is easy to optimize results

Separation is based on the boiling points of the solute molecules so it is not very flexible in terms of optimizing separation

This is a relatively slower technique

The analysis is faster and usually measured in minutes, although it can take as little as a couple of seconds

Usually gives a greater peak or broader band resulting in lower resolution

Provides comparatively better resolution

Uses polar solvents like water or methanol

Uses any solvent that vaporizes

Reviewed by Afsaneh Khetrapal, BSc (Hons)

Additional Review by , MD, PhD

References

  1. http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/Core/Analytical_Chemistry/Instrumental_Analysis/Chromatography/Liquid_Chromatography
  2. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/pdfs/74-177-k.pdf
  3. https://www.jcu.edu.au/advanced-analytical-centre/analytical-facilities/all-instruments/gas-chromatography-liquid-chromatography-gclc
  4. http://cdn.intechopen.com/pdfs/32817.pdf
  5. http://www.chem.ucla.edu/~bacher/General/30BL/gc/theory.html
  6. http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/ac60117a004?journalCode=ancham
  7. http://arlok.com/articles/High-Performance%20Liquid%20Chromatography.pdf
  8. Blumberg LM. Theory of Gas Chromatography. In: Poole CF, editor. Gas Chromatography, First Edition. Elsevier, 2012; pp. 19-78.
  9. Laird CK. Chemical Analysis: Gas Analysis. In: Walt Boyes, editor. Instrumentation Reference Book. Butterworth-Heinemann, 2009; pp. 327-340.

Further Reading

Last Updated: Aug 25, 2016

Read in | English | Español | Français | Deutsch | Português | Italiano | 日本語 | 한국어 | 简体中文 | 繁體中文 | Nederlands | Русский | Svenska | Polski
Comments
  1. Paul Salverda Paul Salverda United States says:

    There are a number of mistakes.  Hydrogen is not an inert gas.  GC column separation is not only by boiling point or vapor pressure. She mentions gas/liquid partitioning herself, which should lead to talking about the wide variety of GC column stationary phases that are necessary for the diversity of GC applications. GC is not only for volatile compounds as separation of gases is a typical application. Many non-volatile compounds can also be derivatized before analysis.  GC methods are only some few seconds to many minutes long. Any solvent that vaporizes can be used, not only the two mentioned.   An LC specialist should talk about all the mistakes in that part of the article.

The opinions expressed here are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of News-Medical.Net.
Post a new comment
Post