Viewpoints: A missing contraception question, Obama's budget blind spot, NEJM on Medicare Advantage

Published on February 23, 2012 at 11:32 PM · No Comments

The New York Times: The Opinionator: Who Decided That This Election Should Be About Sex?
David Brooks and Gail Collins discuss the surprising role debates over contraception, abortion and unwed mothers have played so far in the campaign (2/22).

The Washington Post: The Missing Contraception Question
Can we please get one moment of contraceptive clarity Wednesday night in what may be the final big GOP debate of the year? All it will take is a simple line of questioning pressed by moderator John King (Matt Miller, 2/22).

The Washington Post: Virginia Gov. McDonnell's Abortion Crucible 
Gov. Robert McDonnell and some of his fellow Virginia Republicans are shocked, shocked. It turns out that legislation mandating a costly, coercive, medically unnecessary ultrasound procedure would be physically invasive and personally offensive for thousands of women seeking abortions in the state (2/22).

McClatchy: GOP Goes Back To The 1960s On Birth Control
Ignoring years of public-opinion polls, the GOP is boldly marching backwards into the 1960s to question whether contraception is a legitimate health-care benefit. The target, as always, is President Obama. He issued an executive mandate requiring that free birth control be included in health plans provided to employees of schools, charities and hospitals connected to religiously affiliated institutions. Although the mandate excludes churches, Roman Catholic bishops are in a huff, saying the contraception provision violates the First Amendment and "freedom of religion" (Carl Hiaasen, 2/23).

McClatchy: Catholic Women Must Speak Out
The use of birth control is against Catholic teaching, a sin and part of "a culture of death," as New York's Archbishop Timothy M. Dolan has said. But the majority of Roman Catholic women - 98 percent according to one poll - have used birth control. Like me, many such women have received periodic fundraising letters from the church usually addressed to the woman of the house. They've enrolled their children in Catholic schools and watched their children participate in the sacraments. ... Of 100 Catholic women friends and acquaintances I could name, 99 use artificial birth control. But have we spoken out? No. Instead, we have spoken to each other (Maura Casey, 2/23).

Los Angeles Times: Obama's Budget Blind Spot
On the spending side, the president calls for cuts across a wide range of programs, but his plan is also rife with gimmicks. He touts a 10-year "deficit reduction" of $850 billion from our reduced roles in Iraq and Afghanistan, but virtually nobody believes the country intended to spend that money. … Notably, the budget does nothing to restructure entitlements -; Medicare, Social Security, Medicaid. A leadership budget would focus less on minor program changes and more on major reforms to combat the coming fiscal crisis driven by runaway entitlement spending (David M. Primo, 2/22).

The Washington Post: Mitt Romney's Tax Proposal May Not Be Narrative Campaign Wants
What's important, as Hubbard correctly says, is the story the figures tell about a Romney administration. And that goes something like this: Under a Romney presidency, there would be a major redistribution -; or perhaps it should be called a re-redistribution -; from low-income people who depend on government programs such as Medicaid to higher-income folks who pay taxes (Ezra Klein, 2/22).

The Wall Street Journal: Health Care's Coming Price Revolution
The old-line Marxists used to talk about "heightening the contradictions" of capitalism to make things worse and hasten the revolution. One of the great ironies of the Affordable Care Act is that it may be doing just that (Joseph Rago, 2/23).

The Wall Street Journal: A Tax Reform to Restore America's Prosperity
Higher-income Americans who receive the greatest benefit from rate cuts will see the most significant limits. Middle-income Americans will continue to enjoy tax benefits that favor important priorities such as home ownership, charitable giving, health care, and savings. The result will be a pro-growth tax code that still raises the necessary revenue, retains the existing progressivity, and ensures that middle-income Americans will see real tax relief ( Mitt Romney, 2/23).

The Wall Street Journal: Romney's Tax Reboot
Mr. Romney made the mistake yesterday of distinguishing between deductions for "middle-income families," which he said would be preserved, and for the "top 1 percent," which he said would be on the table. This sounds like a pollster's bad advice. It merely plays into Mr. Obama's class-war theme when Mr. Romney should be stressing growth. But at least Mr. Romney says all deductions would be on the reform table, including those for mortgage interest, state and local taxes and health care (2/23).

Boston Globe: Big Cases On High Court Docket Highlight Need To Allow Cameras
When the Supreme Court announced on Tuesday that it would reconsider its position on affirmative action at public universities - a legal flashpoint since the 1970s - it caught the attention of millions of Americans. With a test of President Obama's health care overhaul already on the docket for April, the coming term promises to be one of the most consequential in memory. It would be a fine chance for the public to learn how the Constitution is applied to legal disputes, and to demystify the court. But the court's own rectitude - emblemized by its refusal to allow cameras to record public hearings - is getting in the way (2/23).

The Philadelphia Inquirer: 'Santorum Of Pennsylvania': 14th Century Public Health Hero
Unlike SNL's Theodoric of York, who at least tried to help people, even as he prescribed bleeding, leeching, worming, boar's vomit, the Caladrius bird, and hanging one upside down from a gibbet to fight illness, Rick Santorum of Pennsylvania only has proscriptions for what ails us, proscriptions that threaten to return us to the unscientific and uncaring days of yore when science and medicine were based on superstition. Questioning his cures, Theodoric of York-; who fictionally lived in the century before the European Renaissance (and popped up in Steve Martin skits in the 1970s) -; wondered whether we should test our "assumptions analytically through experimentation and the scientific method" (Michael Yudell, 2/22).

The Houston Chronicle: Texas Can Lead The Way On Medicaid Reform
The innovation allowed under today's Medicaid program will never come close to closing the gap for the demands on state tax dollars for this federal health care program for the poor. Medicaid is in desperate need of overhaul….Texas has the opportunity to lead the reform movement by pursuing the waiver for an aggressive block grant as envisioned in the legislation (Arlene Wohlgemuth, 2/22).

The Minneapolis Star Tribune: Know The Full Story About Health Plans
The editorial focused on one program. The state groups three programs -- Medicaid, MinnesotaCare and the old General Assistance Medical Care -- into one contract. It's a package deal and must be scrutinized as such…..The editorial focused on one year. But insurance financing is cyclical, containing highs and lows from year to year. The average profit over the past five years for all state public programs is 1.6 percent of revenue, less than the margins reported in the editorial for both Michigan and Wisconsin (Julie Brunner, 2/22).

Read in | English | Español | Français | Deutsch | Português | Italiano | 日本語 | 한국어 | 简体中文 | 繁體中文 | Nederlands | Русский | Svenska | Polski
Comments
The opinions expressed here are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of News-Medical.Net.
Post a new comment
Post