Senators have mental health crises, too

The host

Julie Rovner KHN @jrovner

Julie Rovner is chief Washington correspondent and host of KHN's weekly health policy news podcast, "What the Health?" A noted expert on health policy issues, Julie is the author of the critically praised reference book "Health Care Politics and Policy A to Z," now in its third edition.

Both Republicans and Democrats in Congress reacted with compassion to the news that Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) has checked himself into Walter Reed National Military Medical Center for treatment of clinical depression. The reaction is a far cry from what it would have been 20 or even 10 years ago, as more politicians from both parties are willing to admit they are humans with human frailties.

Meanwhile, former South Carolina governor and GOP presidential candidate Nikki Haley is pushing "competency" tests for politicians over age 75. She has not specified, however, who would determine what the test should include and who would decide if politicians pass or fail.

This week's panelists are Julie Rovner of KHN, Sarah Karlin-Smith of the Pink Sheet, Joanne Kenen of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and Politico, and Rachel Roubein of The Washington Post.

Panelists

• Sarah Karlin-Smith Pink Sheet @SarahKarlin
• Joanne Kenen Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and Politico @JoanneKenen
• Rachel Roubein The Washington Post @rachel_roubein

Among the takeaways from this week's episode:

• Acknowledging a mental health disorder could spell doom for a politician's career in the past, but rather than raising questions about his fitness to serve, Sen. John Fetterman's decision to make his depression diagnosis and treatment public raises the possibility that personal experiences with the health system could make lawmakers better representatives.
• In Medicare news, Sen. Rick Scott (R-Fla.) dropped Medicare and Social Security from his proposal to require that every federal program be specifically renewed every five years. Scott's plan has been hammered by Democrats after President Joe Biden criticized it this month in his State of the Union address.
• Medicare is not politically "untouchable," though. Two Biden administration proposals seek to rein in the high cost of the popular Medicare Advantage program. Those are already proving controversial as well, particularly among Medicare beneficiaries who like the additional benefits that often come with the private-sector plans.
• New studies on the effectiveness of ivermectin and mask use are drawing attention to pandemic preparedness. The study of ivermectin revealed that the drug is not effective against the covid-19 virus even in higher doses, raising the question about how far researchers must go to convince skeptics fed misinformation about using the drug to treat covid. Also, a new analysis of studies on mask use leaned on pre-pandemic studies, potentially undermining mask recommendations for future health crises.
• On the abortion front, abortion rights supporters in Ohio are pushing for a ballot measure enshrining access to the procedure in its state constitution, while a lawyer in Florida is making an unusual "personhood" argument to advocate for a pregnant woman to be released from jail.

Plus for "extra credit," the panelists suggest health policy stories they read this week that they think you should read, too:

Julie Rovner: Stat's "Current Treatments for Cramps Aren't Cutting It. Why Aren't There Better Options," by Calli McMurray

Joanne Kenen: The Atlantic's "Eagles Are Falling, Bears Are Going Blind," by Katherine J. Wu

Rachel Roubein: The Washington Post's "Her Baby Has a Deadly Diagnosis. Her Florida Doctors Refused an Abortion," by Frances Stead Sellers

Sarah Karlin-Smith: DCist's "Locals Who Don't Speak English Need Medical Translators, but Some Say They Don't Always Get the Service," by Amanda Michelle Gomez and Hector Alejandro Arzate

Also mentioned in this week's podcast:

• The Hill's "Nikki Haley: Bernie Sanders Is 'Exactly the Reason' Mental Competency Tests Are Needed," by Niall Stanage
• USA Today's "Idaho Bill Would Criminalize Giving mRNA Vaccines — The Tech Used in Popular COVID Vaccines," by Thao Nguyen
• The Washington Post's "Twenty Governors Are Forming a New Coalition to Support Abortion Rights," by Rachel Roubein with McKenzie Beard
• The Washington Post's "Fla. Lawyer Argues Pregnant Inmate's Fetus Is Being Illegally Detained," by Kyle Melnick

Credits

• Francis Ying Audio producer
• Emmarie Huetteman Editor