Cognitive rehabilitation helps people with acquired brain injury

Cognitive rehabilitation after a serious brain injury or stroke can help the mind in much the same way that physical therapy helps the body, according to a new meta-analysis.

Because the data suggest that treatment may work best when tailored to age, injury, symptoms, and time since injury, the findings may help establish evidence-based treatment guidelines. A full report is in the January issue of Neuropsychology, which is published by the American Psychological Association.

Researchers at the University of South Alabama and the University of North Carolina at Charlotte analyzed and updated the data found in systematic reviews, published in 2000* and 2005**, of several hundred studies of cognitive rehabilitation. The researchers took those studies whose samples and methods were most amenable to rigorous statistical techniques and documented the extent to which various treatments improve the language, attention, memory and other cognitive problems that appear after acquired brain injury (such as from trauma, stroke or loss of oxygen – in other words, not congenital).

The meta-analysis examined 97 articles, comprising 115 studied treatment samples and 45 control samples. These samples collectively included 2,014 individuals who underwent cognitive rehabilitation after brain injury and 870 individuals in a variety of control conditions. The authors of the initial reviews had concluded there was enough evidence to generally support the use of a variety of rehabilitative treatments. To develop specific treatment guidelines, this new analysis documented the extent to which treatment type and timing, origin of the injury, recovery level, and participant age affected the odds of success.

Given the patterns they found, the authors offered initial treatment guidelines:

  • Generally, it is better to start treating patients as early as possible, rather than waiting for a more complete neurological recovery.
  • Even older patients (age 55 and up) may benefit from cognitive rehabilitation, particularly if the brain injury is due to stroke.
  • Clinicians should focus their efforts on direct cognitive skills training in specific cognitive domains (such as attention or visuospatial processing). More holistic, non-targeted interventions appear to be less effective.

Especially if they were treated soon after the event, language training helped older people after stroke with aphasia, problems producing and/or comprehending language. However, language training was still effective, just not as much, when it started more than a year after the stroke.

Attention training helped people with acquired brain injury and seemed to work best with younger patients less than a year after injury. It was the most specific treatment, improving nothing but attention.

Visuospatial training helped stroke patients with visuospatial neglect, the inability to respond or orient to something shown on the side opposite to the site of the injury. Visuospatial training also tended to improve performance in other cognitive domains.

Memory treatment did not produce clear results. Nor did comprehensive treatments that attempted to treat cognitive problems holistically.

Other specific findings emerged. For one thing, patients treated less than a year after injury did better than those treated more than a year later. For another, older patients tended to improve more after stroke than younger patients improved after traumatic brain injury (TBI). However, because strokes are more common in old age and TBI is more common in youth, further research is needed to disentangle the roles of age and injury type.

Thus, in the field of cognitive rehabilitation, one size does not fit all. Additional research should fill remaining gaps in understanding the effectiveness of and optimizing conditions for specific interventions.

http://www.apa.org/

Comments

  1. Craig J. Phillips MRC, BA Craig J. Phillips MRC, BA United States says:

    Dear Friend, I may have contacted you in the past however I would like to remind you that I am available to be service to both you and to brain injury survivors and their families / friends. Please let me introduce myself. My name is Craig J. Phillips. I am a traumatic brain injury survivor and a masters level rehabilitation counselor. I am also an internationally published author and a motivational speaker with a message of encouragement, motivation, empowerment, inspiration and hope.  

    In August of 1967, at the age of 10, I sustained an open skull fracture with right frontal lobe damage and a severe brain contusion, brain stem involvement and a fractured left femur. I remained in a coma for 3 weeks. Although I was not expected to live the night of the car accident in 1967, or succeed beyond high school academically I went onto obtain both my undergraduate and graduate degrees *About Page*http://wp.me/P3atD-D... and my Professional Page http://wp.me/P3atD-xP...

    On February 6, 2007 I created *Second Chance to Live *http://secondchanceto... to share the principles and strategies that have encouraged, motivated, empowered and given me hope to succeed beyond all reasonable expectations -- when giving up would have been much easier. You may read what several individuals have said about the influence that Second Chance to Live has had upon their lives on my *Testimonial / Endorsement Page* http://wp.me/P3atD-nD....

    To date I have written 508 articles for Second Chance to Live. These articles are listed with in my *Site Map* http://wp.me/P3atD-1H.... Second Chance to Live has been published internationally. See my Publications page http://wp.me/P3atD-oK.... I am available to be of service to you, your mission and vision. Please see my *Speaker Page* http://wp.me/P3atD-3A... and my* Media Page* http://wp.me/P3atD-d0....

    I have added a feature to Second Chance to Live to enable individuals to translate Second Chance to Live into their language http://wp.me/p3atD-FM

    Please consider using Second Chance to Live http://secondchancetolive.wordpress.com as a helpful resource. Thank you.

    I look forward to being of service to you and those individuals who have been impacted by trauma, abuse or adversity.

    Please also feel free to share my information with other groups, organizations and associations. Thank you.

    Craig J. Phillips MRC, BA
    Second Chance to Live

    Our circumstances are not meant to keep us down, but they are meant to build us up!

The opinions expressed here are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of News Medical.
You might also like... ×
Study reveals damaging role of immune system in severe brain infection