Dec 24 2009
Fitch Ratings takes the following rating action on Northwestern Medical
Faculty Foundation, IL as part of its continuous surveillance effort:
--Approximately $75 million Illinois Health Facility Authority revenue
bonds, series 1998, upgraded to 'A+' from 'A'.
The Rating Outlook is revised to Stable from Positive.
RATING RATIONALE:
--The upgrade reflects Northwestern Medical Faculty Foundation's (NMFF)
sustained operating profitability and positive volume trends.
--Strong nationwide clinical reputation, and affiliation with
Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine (FSM), a part of
Northwestern University (revenue bonds rated 'AAA' by Fitch) and
Northwestern Memorial Hospital (the hospital).
--Satisfactory liquidity position.
--The main offsetting rating factor is the uncertainty surrounding
proposed physician payment reductions that are currently being debated
in the U.S. Congress that are part of the Obama Administration's health
reform efforts.
--The Stable Rating Outlook is based on Fitch's expectation that
operating margins remain in positive territory despite potential Center
for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) payment reductions and
consistent balance sheet measures.
KEY RATING DRIVER(S):
--Continuation of healthy earnings trends despite potential CMS
reimbursement modifications.
--Maintenance of adequate liquidity balances and modest leverage
indicators.
SECURITY:
The bonds secured by a security interest in unrestricted receivables, a
mortgage on certain real property, and a debt service reserve fund.
CREDIT SUMMARY:
Since Fitch assigned a Positive Rating Outlook in September 2007, NMMF
continues to produce healthy operating margins. Although not as strong
as the fiscal year (FY) 2005-2007's average of 8%, NMMF produced a 6.5%
operating margin in FY08 and a 6.1% operating margin in FY09. FY09
numbers are preliminary and based on draft audited financial statements.
Utilization trends continue to be robust with total physician encounters
increasing 8% in FY08 and 5.6% in FY09. NMMF has been able to maintain
performance despite decreases in reimbursement from governmental
programs. This is due to NMFF's ability to leverage its size and
clinical reputation to garner favorable commercial health plan
contracts, improve physician productivity, enhance organizational
efficiencies, and control practice expenses. Cash flow flexibility is
also supported by NMFF's ability to suspend certain payments to FSM.
Outside of the dean's tax, certain transfers to FSM are discretionary
and may be deferred, which NMFF has done in the past.
NMFF's main credit strength is the caliber of its multi-specialty group
that is highly regarded nationwide for its clinical and research
excellence. The physician group has grown significantly to 670 doctors
in FY09 from 537 in FY05. Although NMFF, FSM, and the hospital are
separate corporations that issue their own debt, Fitch believes the
success of the three entities is interdependent. NMFF is the teaching
faculty for FSM, and NMFF's physicians account for about 60% of the
hospital's admissions. Fitch views this interdependent relationship
favorably. Further demonstrating the close working relationship of the
three organizations, the hospital and FSM typically jointly support
practice development and recruitment for NMFF.
In addition to the healthy profitability, financial strength is
demonstrated by good debt service coverage, adequate liquidity, and a
low debt burden. EBITDA debt service coverage is very solid at 3.7 times
(x) in FY08 and 4.5x for FY09. Moreover, adjusted EBITDA debt service
coverage after adding back in the contributions to FSM is healthy at
7.4x in FY08 and 5.9x in FY09. As of Aug. 31, 2009, $109 million of
unrestricted cash and investments amounts to 88 days operating expenses
or 148% of long-term debt. The debt burden is light with maximum annual
debt service representing only 1.3% of revenues. NMFF indicates that it
does not have any significant capital plans or long-term debt plans over
the next several years.
Fitch's main credit concern is the uncertainty surrounding proposed
physician payment reductions from CMS that are supposed to cut Medicare
reimbursement by about 21% on March 1, 2010. However, the U.S. Congress
is currently debating a modification to the proposed CMS reductions as
part of the Obama Administration's health reform efforts with the
potential of moderating and extending the reimbursement cuts. With
Medicare representing 30% of its gross revenues, a significant decline
in revenues could have a negative impact on NMFF's earnings and cash
flow. Nonetheless, NMMF maintains budgetary flexibility as about 10%-15%
of its compensation expenses are based on incentives for revenue
performance and achievement of NMFF's clinical, research and educational
mission.
Source:
Northwestern Medical
Faculty Foundation