Push for plain cigarette packaging reaches new heights

Labor’s plain packaging laws for cigarettes allow the commonwealth to advertise a political message without paying for the privilege and acquire the property of tobacco companies, the High Court has been told.

According to Big tobacco yesterday, Labor's plain packaging legislation was unconstitutional because it amounted to an acquisition of property without “just terms” under section 51 of the Constitution. British American Tobacco, Japan Tobacco International, Philip Morris and Imperial Tobacco told the Full Bench of the High Court the plan would benefit the Commonwealth by giving it control over the content displayed on the packets.

Under the federal government's laws all cigarettes and tobacco products will have to be sold in drab olive-brown packs from December. Large graphic health warnings will dominate the packs, and the manufacturers' brand names - such as Camel or Winfield Blue - will be written in a small generic font.

Alan Archibald QC, barrister for Philip Morris, said the plan effectively “conscripts the packet to service (the Commonwealth's) purposes”. Gavan Griffith QC, for Japan Tobacco, which sells Camels said the packs could be used as billboards and Canberra could just as easily promote its own messages including “pay your tax on time” or “drive safely”. “What the commonwealth has done is to prescribe the message that the commonwealth desires to have put on that billboard,” he said. “It's acquiring our billboard, in effect.” Imperial Tobacco's senior counsel, Bret Walker, said the cigarette companies were like a frog that realized it was about to be cooked.

However, the court also heard the Commonwealth could only be said to have unlawfully acquired big tobacco's property if it benefited in some way. Many of the High Court justices on Tuesday questioned how that could possibly be the case. “The Commonwealth doesn't have the right to use your trademark as a result of this legislation,” Chief Justice Robert French said.

Justice Kenneth Hayne repeatedly asked how the commonwealth would benefit by forcing manufacturers to run large health warnings on the front and back of the plain packs. The tobacco companies responded by arguing the government wasn't paying for the space. Neither was Quitline, whose stop-smoking helpline number will appear on the packs.

Justice Susan Kiefel wanted to know why it couldn't be said the Commonwealth was simply involved in a “considerable restriction” of the manufacturers' trademarks without itself benefiting. “The loss of something may not equate to the commonwealth's acquisition,” she said.

Federal Attorney-General Nicola Roxon spoke to reporters outside the court before the three-day hearing began. “Regulating the way tobacco is sold in Australia is something that is lawful for any parliament and any government to do,” she said. “Over many decades we've taken steps to introduce tobacco-control measures and this is the next step.”

The case is the first such in the world, and will be closely watched by other governments across the world who are considering similar plans. The hearing is expected to run until Thursday with a judgment due by mid-year.

Dr. Ananya Mandal

Written by

Dr. Ananya Mandal

Dr. Ananya Mandal is a doctor by profession, lecturer by vocation and a medical writer by passion. She specialized in Clinical Pharmacology after her bachelor's (MBBS). For her, health communication is not just writing complicated reviews for professionals but making medical knowledge understandable and available to the general public as well.

Citations

Please use one of the following formats to cite this article in your essay, paper or report:

  • APA

    Mandal, Ananya. (2018, August 23). Push for plain cigarette packaging reaches new heights. News-Medical. Retrieved on July 14, 2024 from https://www.news-medical.net/news/20120418/Push-for-plain-cigarette-packaging-reaches-new-heights.aspx.

  • MLA

    Mandal, Ananya. "Push for plain cigarette packaging reaches new heights". News-Medical. 14 July 2024. <https://www.news-medical.net/news/20120418/Push-for-plain-cigarette-packaging-reaches-new-heights.aspx>.

  • Chicago

    Mandal, Ananya. "Push for plain cigarette packaging reaches new heights". News-Medical. https://www.news-medical.net/news/20120418/Push-for-plain-cigarette-packaging-reaches-new-heights.aspx. (accessed July 14, 2024).

  • Harvard

    Mandal, Ananya. 2018. Push for plain cigarette packaging reaches new heights. News-Medical, viewed 14 July 2024, https://www.news-medical.net/news/20120418/Push-for-plain-cigarette-packaging-reaches-new-heights.aspx.

Comments

  1. Jacob Jacob Australia says:

    The questions from the bench seem to indicate their views on the matter which is encouraging because it seems amazing to me that these companies think they can dictate to the government.

The opinions expressed here are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of News Medical.
Post a new comment
Post

While we only use edited and approved content for Azthena answers, it may on occasions provide incorrect responses. Please confirm any data provided with the related suppliers or authors. We do not provide medical advice, if you search for medical information you must always consult a medical professional before acting on any information provided.

Your questions, but not your email details will be shared with OpenAI and retained for 30 days in accordance with their privacy principles.

Please do not ask questions that use sensitive or confidential information.

Read the full Terms & Conditions.

You might also like...
E-cigarette users experience similar DNA changes to specific cheek cells as smokers