One-side parathyroid surgery has poorer long-term outcomes

Dr James Norman, MD and his partners at the Norman Parathyroid Center have published a landmark study in this week's Journal of the American College of Surgeons describing how the operation they developed and advocated for more than 19 years has significantly poorer long-term outcomes. The unilateral or "one-side" parathyroid surgical procedure to remove parathyroid tumors from patients suffering from hyperparathyroidism is a dramatic change from the large neck operation that it replaced. Dr Norman and his partners have published many articles touting the benefits of the smaller, one-side operation, a procedure that has become the standard operation world-wide. Long-term followup, however, shows that many patients having a one-side operation will need another operation some years later to remove a second tumor.

"We changed parathyroid surgery forever in the mid 1990's by developing and advocating the use of technology to allow one-side neck operations to remove parathyroid tumors," said Norman. "We have performed over 17,500 parathyroid operations and unfortunately, quite a few patients who we believed were cured after a one-side operation began showing up with another parathyroid tumor between 3 and 15 years later. They obviously had a second smaller tumor that we did not see. In contrast, those patients in whom we examined all four parathyroid glands had a second tumor removed 20% of the time and their long-term cure rates remain near 100%."

"We began noticing big differences in cure rates about 6 years ago and thus began our avoidance of one-side parathyroid surgery," stated Dr Douglas Politz, a co-author. "Fortunately for the patients, the new mini-parathyroid operation to look at all 4 glands (both sides) is actually smaller and faster than the one-side operation we developed 18 years ago using techniques we are teaching with videos online."

"This is a very significant change in surgical practice," stated Dr Lee Metchick, an endocrinologist in Central Florida. "If one parathyroid tumor is removed and a smaller, second tumor remains, the patient doesn't achieve the full benefits of the operation." 


Norman Parathyroid Center


The opinions expressed here are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of News Medical.
Post a new comment
You might also like...
What are the clinical considerations of proton radiotherapy for individuals with locally advancing breast cancer?