A real-world trial has tested the effectiveness – and revealed the challenges – of adapting behavioral therapy to the online world.
Families in regional and rural NSW have gained virtual parenting support through a live trial led by researchers at UNSW Sydney. The findings were recently published in the journal Behavior Therapy.
The trial was aimed at young children aged between 1.5 and 4 years old with ongoing behavioral problems, such as persistent tantrums, defiance, and aggressive behavior. They had all been referred to the program by medical professionals or a community parenting service.
This online intervention was powerful for improving child behavior. Almost 90 per cent of children who completed treatment rated in the normal range of functioning by the end of the program.”
Dr Georgette Fleming, postdoctoral research fellow at UNSW Science’s School of Psychology and lead author of the study
Parents also benefited greatly, with findings showing that online parent management training can lead to large and observable improvements in effective parenting skills.
The therapy took place over an average of 10 parent-child play sessions. The therapist – who was watching via a live video call – paid close attention to the child’s disruptive behaviors and the parent’s response. They then coached the parent in how to manage different negative behaviors as they occurred in real time via a wireless headset worn by the parent.
This is the first time online parent management training has been tested in a real-world setting – that is, delivered by community practitioners to families in regional and rural areas. The intervention was run in partnership with parenting service Karitane.
“It’s an exciting step in taking university-based research into the real world,” Dr Fleming says.
The findings couldn’t have come at a better time, with COVID-19 prompting many in-person psychological therapies to move online.
“We hope this effectiveness study will be encouraging to practitioners and families at a time where anxieties and uncertainties are high,” says Dr Fleming.
The UNSW Parent-Child Research Clinic, which Dr Fleming works at, is currently transitioning its services online to comply with physical distancing measures.
Challenges in the Australian setting
The trial gave the researchers an opportunity to assess future challenges Australians face in receiving mental health services. Access to funding is a key barrier.
Medicare only offers 10 subsidized sessions per calendar year. Many psychological interventions, including the intensive one we delivered, exceed this number. With limited subsidized funding, many people might stop intervention prematurely.”
Dr Georgette Fleming
The availability of online mental health services is another issue: subsidized Medicare funding for online psychological programs are usually only available to residents in certain areas of regional and rural NSW. Due to COVID-19, these guidelines have been expanded, with Medicare-subsidized services now available to those residing in metropolitan areas as well.
“While this is a promising step forward, it’s currently unclear whether the improvement to the accessibility of online mental health services will last beyond the pandemic. This is unfortunate, because treating problematic behaviors in the place where they actually happen – the home – is likely to be more powerful than treating them in artificial clinic settings,” says Dr Fleming.
The research team also had concerns about the whether the Australian internet could support the early-intervention program.
To curb any connectivity problems before they happened, study participants were given a wireless internet dongle where they didn’t have stable home internet.
Fortunately, this approach meant that only one family needed to withdraw due to poor internet. However, Dr Fleming and her team have concerns for future programs – particularly with more Australians working from home than ever.
“The question of the Australian internet remains the black box of online psychological intervention for Australia,” she says.
Scaffolding for future research
Dr Fleming notes that as a preliminary study, the research has its limitations – most importantly a small sample size (only 27 mothers and their children participated, 10 of which didn’t complete the study). She hopes to expand the study to build on the initial findings.
Next, we plan to expand the study to include a bigger sample size and compare the therapy to other interventions. We also hope to follow-up with families involved in this trial to see whether the improvements they made were sustained over time.”
Dr Georgette Fleming
Continued research and improved access to online services is particularly important in Australia, given the size of the country and its population spread.
“While families in metropolitan areas are currently facing barriers in accessing face-to-face mental health services, geographical barriers make this a constant challenge for those in regional and rural NSW,” says Dr Fleming.
“We hope our research lays the groundwork for integrating online parent management training into community services-as-usual in the long term.”
Study explores parents' struggle with children's avid eating behaviors