A comprehensive review of 74 studies explores how beer, wine, and liquor affect liver health, uncovering potential differences in risk while challenging the perception that red wine offers health benefits.
Study: Does Alcohol Type Matter? Investigating the Effects of Beer, Wine, and Liquor on Liver Health. Image credit: View Apart/Shutterstock.com
Heavy alcohol consumption damages the liver regardless of the type of beverage consumed, but the choice of drink may influence liver health at lower levels of consumption, according to a narrative review published in the journal Nutrients.
Investigating beverage-specific liver risks
Excessive alcohol consumption has consistently been linked to negative liver health consequences. Habitual overconsumption of alcohol can lead to alcohol-associated liver disease, which can progress from simple steatosis to end-stage liver diseases, like cirrhosis.
The majority of studies investigating the health impact of alcohol have primarily focused on the volume and frequency of intake. However, less information is currently available regarding the impact of different types of alcohol on overall and liver health, despite significant variations in alcohol content and chemical profile among popular alcoholic beverages.
The authors of this review article aimed to comprehensively examine the impact of the three most common types of alcoholic beverages, beer, wine, and liquor, on liver health. They searched major electronic databases and identified 74 relevant studies, including 56 preclinical and 18 clinical studies, on alcohol type and liver health.
How beer, wine, and liquor affect liver health
The comprehensive review of selected preclinical and clinical studies revealed that excessive consumption of alcohol is consistently associated with increased risk of liver disease, irrespective of the type of alcohol consumed. At low-to-moderate intake, however, differences in the liver health impacts of different alcoholic beverages appeared to be more pronounced.
The studies comparing health effects of beer, wine, and liquor generally suggested that liquor intake may have the strongest negative impact on liver health, followed by beer and wine, respectively.
A few preclinical studies highlighted potential health benefits of certain types of beer that contain antioxidant-rich components, such as hops. However, hop-rich beers often have higher alcohol concentrations. Most of the available evidence linked beer intake to poor liver health in populations with existing health conditions. Given that beer is the most common alcoholic beverage in the U.S., more studies are needed to investigate the association between beer intake and liver health, particularly in healthy individuals. In particular, expanded research on hop content and different types of beer is warranted.
Low-to-moderate intake of wine appeared to be less harmful for liver health than beer and liquor, although healthier dietary and lifestyle habits among wine drinkers may partly explain this association. Among wine types, red wine showed the most promise as less detrimental to liver health. However, other types of wine, including white and high-antioxidant fruit-based wines, need further investigation.
The majority of human studies investigating the liver health impact of red wine are observational, and many confounding factors are likely to influence the findings. Therefore, the liver health outcomes reported by these studies should be interpreted with caution. The authors emphasized that red wine itself is not health-promoting and that some potentially beneficial effects may be attributable to its non-alcoholic components.
The review also highlighted a recently defined liver disease category known as metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease with increased alcohol intake (MetALD). Although less information is currently available, this disease was identified as an independent risk factor for all-cause mortality. More research is needed to understand the impact of different types of alcohol on the disease risk, because the interaction between food and alcohol can potentially modulate health outcomes.
Preclinical studies exclusively focusing on liquor or pure ethanol, particularly at a concentration of 20% or higher, generally reported adverse liver health outcomes. However, although one study of predominantly liquor-drinking men found no association between alcohol intake and the risk of hepatocellular carcinoma, other studies linked liquor consumption to an increased risk. Exclusive liquor or cocktail intake was also linked to increased odds of liver fibrosis, even in non-heavy drinkers.
One cohort study investigating the health impact of binge drinking reported that weekly binge drinking among predominantly beer or liquor drinkers was associated with adverse liver events compared to infrequent binge drinking (1–11 episodes per year). As reported in this study, the estimated hazard ratio was higher among beer drinkers than liquor drinkers in the context of binge drinking.
Heavy drinking damages the liver regardless of beverage type
This comprehensive review of available evidence indicates that heavy alcohol intake can significantly damage the liver, irrespective of the type of alcohol consumed. Liquor, such as whiskey, vodka, and rum, which typically have a higher alcohol concentration, appears to have the strongest negative impact on liver health, as compared to beer and wine. However, evidence of sex-specific differences in alcohol-related liver damage remains limited, and more research involving females is needed.
There is still a major gap in research on types of alcohol, especially the comparison between different types of liquor, wine, and beer, and emerging beverages like hard seltzers. Future studies should consider crucial confounding factors, including consumption patterns and volume, diet, socioeconomic status, and lifestyle habits, for a more conclusive interpretation.
As stated by the authors, this review is limited by the lack of specific research studies conducted on alcohol type and liver health. The predominantly observational nature of human studies also limits the ability to establish causation. Expanded research is needed to explain the many unknowns regarding alcohol type and liver health.
The authors emphasized that abstaining from alcohol or consuming it infrequently in small quantities is likely the best option for health.
Journal reference:
- Akili IS et al. (2026). Does Alcohol Type Matter? Investigating the Effects of Beer, Wine, and Liquor on Liver Health. Nutrients. 18(22), 3749. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/nu18223749. https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/18/22/3749