Four simple criteria for a bacterial strain to be called probiotic

Today, the word probiotic is used to describe all kinds of "good" microorganisms in foods and supplements: those found in yogurt or fermented sauerkraut, or even those found naturally in the human digestive tract. But this overly broad use of the term poses a scientific problem: it does not convey a distinction between bacterial strains that have a possible health benefit in humans, and strains that have a demonstrated health benefit, as shown in a human study. The frequent misuse of the term reduces transparency for consumers and sows confusion about what probiotic consumption really achieves.

Already, scientists have come up with a very specific definition of probiotics: "live microorganisms that, when administered in adequate amounts, confer a health benefit on the host". And now, an open-access paper published in Frontiers in Microbiology builds on this definition, describing four simple criteria for accurate use of the word probiotic. The paper was published by eight scientists, including two board members from the International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics (ISAPP), and was initiated by IPA Europe.

The scientists agreed that for a bacterial strain or strains to be called a probiotic, it should be: (1) pure and properly named (or "characterized"); (2) safe for its intended purpose; (3) supported by at least one well-designed human clinical trial that shows a health benefit; and (4) maintained alive in the product in a high enough dose to convey its health benefits, all the way through its shelf life.

Correct use of the term probiotic, per these criteria, will give consumers better transparency about the benefits they can expect when they consume products that contain live microorganisms. It will also allow them to weigh the costs and benefits of different products in the marketplace.

Going forward, the authors encourage scientists and companies to use these minimum criteria for identifying true probiotics. But until the time when the term is used correctly in all scientific papers and on all product labels, consumers should not assume that the word probiotic guarantees a health benefit.