What makes a favorite sweet treat so rewarding? Researchers examine how the brain responds to food and money, with potential implications for financial incentives designed to encourage healthier eating.

Study: Sweet Rewards: Preferred Candy and Money Elicit Equivalent Reward Positivity Responses. Image Credit: Bohdan Malitskiy / Shutterstock
In a recent study published in the journal Nutrients, researchers found that volunteers displayed comparable neural reward responses when told they had earned a favorite candy or money. The research may help inform the design of financial incentives to improve dietary behavior.
The research was conducted by scientists from the Departments of Psychology and Nutrition, Dietetics, and Food Science and the Neuroscience Center at Brigham Young University, in collaboration with researchers from California State University, Dominguez Hills, USA.
Background
Food preferences and the brain’s response to rewarding foods can influence eating habits, with implications for physical and mental health. Healthy eating habits can also reduce the risk of obesity, depression, and type 2 diabetes.
Food rewards may affect eating behavior through brain pathways related to motivation and pleasure. Previous studies report inconsistent findings about whether more highly preferred foods produce stronger neural reward responses. Monetary incentives can encourage healthier food choices and may affect consumption or weight-related outcomes. Comparing the brain's response to food and money could help explain how financial incentives influence eating habits. Further research is needed to establish how neural reward responses relate to food intake.
About the study
Adults aged 18-55 years were eligible for recruitment through the university’s psychology participant pool and by community flyers. Eligibility criteria included English fluency and the absence of pregnancy, lactation, uncorrected vision problems, head injuries involving loss of consciousness, metabolic or neurological disorders, and current psychiatric or eating disorders.
Of 178 enrollees, 20 were excluded because of eligibility disclosures, missing or unusable electroencephalography (EEG) data, or dislike of all offered candies. The final sample consisted of 158 participants aged 18-28 years, with a mean age of 20.57 years; 50.6% were female and 83.5% were White. Brigham Young University’s Institutional Review Board approved the study, and all participants provided written informed consent.
Before testing, participants followed instructions concerning sleep, caffeine, vigorous activity, and fasting. Participants completed a food preference questionnaire and a hunger visual analog scale (VAS). The highest-rated candy for each participant was selected as the food reward. Nearly 94% of participants reported liking their selected candy a lot.
Volunteers then completed three computerized tasks in a random order, choosing between two virtual doors to earn or lose candy or money, or to receive positive or negative performance feedback. Each task included 100 trials, with outcomes programmed as 50% favorable and 50% unfavorable, independent of door choice. Participants received five fun-size candies and $5 after completing all three tasks. The performance-feedback task offered no tangible reward.
The researchers recorded EEG using 128 electrodes. Reward positivity (RewP) is a brief change in the brain’s electrical activity associated with favorable outcomes and serves as a marker of reward processing. After preprocessing, the RewP amplitude was measured 200–300 milliseconds after feedback. They tested differences using paired-samples t-tests and equivalence tests, with predefined equivalence bounds based on previous research.
Differences in participant numbers across comparisons reflected the exclusion of unusable EEG data or recordings that did not meet the required reliability threshold.
Study results
All three tasks showed the RewP effect: responses were larger after favorable than after unfavorable outcomes. This effect was statistically significant across all three tasks.
The comparison of candy and money included 154 participants, and the researchers found no significant difference between responses to the two rewards. Further testing confirmed that the difference was sufficiently small to establish practical equivalence between the neural responses.
The comparison between candy rewards and positive performance feedback included 146 participants. The results were inconclusive, with insufficient evidence to establish either a statistically significant difference or practical equivalence between the two experimental conditions.
For the monetary reward versus positive performance-feedback comparison, 150 participants were included. Monetary rewards produced significantly larger RewP amplitudes than feedback alone, with a small effect size. Equivalence testing did not support practical equivalence. The practical importance of this difference remains uncertain.
The authors suggested that RewP may reflect both successful goal attainment and the motivational value of a reward, but the experiment could not distinguish between these mechanisms.
Further analyses found no significant correlations of body mass index (BMI) or hunger scores with RewP amplitudes. The RewP measurements demonstrated high reliability. Uneven representation across BMI categories and the absence of BMI adjustment in equivalence tests limited conclusions about BMI’s influence on neural reward responses.
Conclusions
The findings suggest that feedback associated with earning a preferred candy or money elicits practically equivalent RewP responses. The results offer preliminary evidence that the brain's response to food and money may matter when designing financial incentives to change dietary behavior.
The study measured brain responses to reward feedback rather than responses to physically receiving money or consuming candy. Whether participants found candy and money equally motivating or pleasurable remains unknown. The study did not measure food intake or establish whether neural responses predicted eating behavior.
The young, predominantly White sample recruited from a single university setting, along with fasting requirements and the use of candy, limits how widely the findings can be applied. The researchers also did not record the time of testing or how long participants had gone without eating.
Future studies should vary subjective reward value and magnitude, examine reward loss and repeated exposure, test different foods and hunger levels in more diverse participants, and relate neural responses to dietary intake.
Source:
Journal reference:
- Carbine, K. A., Kilgrow, J., LeCheminant, J. D., Espinoza, A., Aldana, J., & Larson, M. J. (2026). Sweet Rewards: Preferred Candy and Money Elicit Equivalent Reward Positivity Responses. Nutrients. 18(22), 3841. DOI: 10.3390/nu18223841, https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/18/22/3841