Why is it that some people love to exercise, and others hate it? Most people would assume it's all due to genetics, but a new Baylor College of Medicine led study in mice shows for the first time that a different molecular level of regulation - epigenetics - plays a key role in determining one's innate drive to exercise. Epigenetics refers to molecular mechanisms that determine which genes are turned on or off in different cell types. Since epigenetic mechanisms are inherently more malleable than genetics, the findings suggest a potential way to help 'program' people to enjoy being more physically active.
Today, in the journal Nature Communications, Baylor researchers and colleagues report the surprising creation of an 'epigenetic couch potato' mouse. They found that in neurons within a part of the brain called the hypothalamus, changes in DNA methylation - the addition of methyl chemical tags in the DNA - have a major impact on levels of voluntary exercise behavior.
"We study developmental programming, which refers to how the environment during development can have a long term impact on risk of disease," said corresponding author, Dr. Robert A. Waterland, professor of pediatrics - nutrition at the USDA/ARS Children's Nutrition Research Center at Baylor and Texas Children's Hospital.
Over the last several years, the researchers studied various mouse models to understand developmental programming of energy balance, that is, the balance of calories consumed vs. those burned off. A prolonged positive energy balance leads to obesity. Remarkably, whether the early environmental influence was fetal growth restriction, infant overnutrition, or maternal exercise during pregnancy, the long-term effect on energy balance was always due to persistent changes in physical activity, not food intake.
"Our earlier findings suggested that establishment of one's physical activity 'set point' can be affected by early environment, and that this may involve epigenetics," said Waterland, who also is a professor of molecular and human genetics and a member of the Dan L Duncan Comprehensive Cancer Center at Baylor.
How the brain regulates the body's energy balance
In the current study, Waterland and his colleagues designed an experiment to directly test whether DNA methylation in the brain affects energy balance. They focused on the hypothalamus, a brain region that plays a central role in energy balance, and in particular, studied a specialized subset of hypothalamic neurons called AgRP neurons, famous for their role in regulating food intake.
The researchers disrupted DNA methylation in AgRP neurons by disabling the Dnmt3a gene. Dnmt3a is responsible for adding methyl groups to DNA, particularly in the brain during early postnatal life. The results showed that, indeed, DNA methylation was dramatically reduced in AgRP neurons of these mice. The investigators then tested whether these animals gained or lost weight when compared to normal mice.
We expected that interfering with DNA methylation in AgRP neurons would result in major changes in the animals' weight. Somewhat disappointingly, however, the Dnmt3a-deficient mice were only slightly fatter than those that were not deficient."
Dr. Harry MacKay, postdoctoral fellow in the Waterland lab and first author of the study
But when the researchers explored the cause of this change in energy balance, things got more interesting. The team expected to find differences in food intake between normal and Dnmt3a-deficient mice. But there were none. Instead, they found a major difference in spontaneous physical exercise.
The researchers placed running wheels in the animals' cages for eight weeks and measured how much they ran each night. Normal male mice ran about 6 Km (3,7 miles) every night, but the Dnmt3a-deficient mice ran only half as much and, accordingly, lost less fat. Importantly, detailed treadmill studies showed that, although they ran only half as much as normal mice, the Dnmt3a-deficient mice were just as capable of running. They had the ability, but appeared to lack the desire.
"Our findings suggest that epigenetic mechanisms, such as DNA methylation, that are established in the brain during fetal or early postnatal life, play a major role in determining individual propensity for exercise," Waterland said. "Nowadays, as decreases in physical activity contribute to the worldwide obesity epidemic, it is increasingly important to understand how all of this works."
MacKay, H., et al. (2019) DNA methylation in AgRP neurons regulates voluntary exercise behavior in mice. Nature Communications. doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-13339-3.