Mechanisms preserving cell identity are based on status of proteins housing DNA

The inheritance, not only of DNA, but of changes to proteins that package it, maintains the identity of cells as they multiply, a new study finds.

Led by researchers at the NYU School of Medicine, the study sheds light on the process by which each cell transmits its identity to the next cellular generation as it multiplies by dividing in two during development. All cells have the same, complete set of DNA, but each is programmed to activate or silence certain genes, determining whether they become, for instance, heart cells instead of intestinal cells, researchers say.

Published online on October 31 in Cell, the new study confirms that mechanisms preserving cell identity are based on how DNA is packaged. With the nuclei of cells, chains of molecular DNA are known to be wrapped around sets of proteins called histones in repeating units called nucleosomes, all within the larger superstructure called chromatin.

Further, the "tails" of the histones are known to extend outside of this wrapping, making them available for chemical changes that determine whether a chromatin region is "open," with the DNA accessible, or tightly compacted, with the genes residing there silenced. The current study authors devised a method to track whether chemical modifications to histones in nucleosomes were accurately passed from a parent cell to the same DNA regions in the two cells it forms upon division.

Based on our new method, experiments suggested that compaction based on histone modifications at key positions is a fundamental feature of inheritance in cells, with the related silencing passed on to keep genes from being expressed in the wrong context."

Thelma Escobar, PhD, study first author  and postdoctoral scholar in the Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Pharmacology at NYU School of Medicine

Mapping inherited nucleosome changes

The research team developed a system in which "old" nucleosomes, those positioned throughout a parent cell's DNA, could be tagged before the DNA was copied as a prerequisite to cell division.

Researchers then used the specificity of the CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing system to attach a molecule called biotin - but only to those nucleosomes present within a single gene of their choice. That in turn let them follow the fate of these marked nucleosomes in genes known to occur in either open or silent chromatin as the cell copied its DNA.

The new method revealed that only the nucleosomes from silent, compacted chromatin were inherited? ending up at the same locale on the newly replicated DNA as they were in the parent DNA. The nucleosomes from the open chromatin were not inherited, and were distributed widely throughout the newly copied chromatin.

Based on their experiments, the authors argue that chemical modifications to histones that foster chromatin compaction are inherited as a fundamental property preserving a cell's identity. Open chromatin, on the other hand, did not rely on this "positional inheritance," as its DNA can be activated as needed by regulatory proteins that interacted with the DNA directly.

Furthermore, the research team found that only within compacted, silent chromatin could the proteins responsible for chemically modifying histone tails recognize ("read") modifications in parental nucleosomes and then duplicate ("write") them on newly forming nucleosomes.

The study also suggests that histones forming nucleosomes in silent chromatin may be escorted to the proper place in replicating DNA by novel chaperone proteins, which the researchers are currently seeking to identify.

"Strikingly, it may be through gene repression that histone modifications show a heritable gene regulatory system not present in more primitive cells like bacteria, potentially playing a role in the greater complexity of human cells," says senior study author Danny Reinberg, PhD, the Terry and Mel Karmazin Professor of Biochemistry and Molecular Pharmacology at NYU Langone Health. "At the same time, cancer arises in some cases from this very complexity - as cells that randomly lose compaction due to a loss of histone chemical modifications see their usually silenced genes become active."

"In this way, cancer cells evolve to overcome treatments or limits on their growth, and we hope the current work will suggest new ways to stop this," says Reinberg, also an investigator with the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.