Women taking beta-blockers for hypertension with no prior history of cardiovascular disease (CVD) have a nearly 5% higher risk for heart failure than men when they present to hospitals with acute coronary syndrome, according to new research published today in Hypertension, an American Heart Association journal.
Beta-blockers are medications that reduce high blood pressure and are prescribed for adults with hypertension, a leading cause of CVD.
In this study, researchers analyzed the effects of beta-blockers on men and women with hypertension and no history of CVD after presenting with acute coronary syndromes. The following incidence of heart failure was recorded to determine if the medication caused different outcomes depending on biological differences.
Past research on the effects of beta-blockers included a majority of participants who were men, so we sought to examine how sex/gender plays a role in patient outcomes."
Raffaele Bugiardini, M.D, Study Lead Author and Professor, Department of Cardiology, University of Bologna
"Women are historically underrepresented in most clinical studies on hypertension. It's important to include an equal split of male and female patients in future research, which could shed light on disparities and actionable treatments."
The study analyzed information from the International Survey of Acute Coronary Syndromes (ISACS) Archives, the ISACS-TC, and the EMMACE-3X clinical registries from October 2010 to July 2018. The research included data from 13,764 adults in 12 European countries who had hypertension and no prior history of cardiovascular disease. Patients were classified by sex/gender and then separated into two groups: those taking beta-blockers and those who were not.
Researchers found that among the participants taking beta-blockers:
- women had a 4.6% higher rate of heart failure than men when presenting to the hospital with the acute coronary syndrome
- the mortality of both men and women with heart failure was approximately seven times that of patients with acute myocardial infarction and no heart failure complications
"What we found presents a solid case for a re-examination of the use of beta-blocker therapy for women with hypertension. For women who have no history of cardiovascular disease and only hypertension, we think it is incredibly important for them to regulate their blood pressure through diet and exercise," Bugiardini noted.
"It's possible that the increased risk of heart failure for women is due to an interaction between hormone replacement therapy and beta-blockers, though this information was not collected or tested in our study. This and other potential factors need to be investigated in more depth."
Researchers noted some limitations. Since the study was observational, results may have some variance and additional data is needed for confirmation. However, a randomized controlled trial of beta-blocker therapy in patients with hypertension may not be considered ethical since it would be designed to confirm risk and not benefit.
The study did not include, nor have information for, the length of time patients used a previous treatment or dosing of beta-blockers.
Through its signature, women's initiative, Go Red for Women®, the American Heart Association has advocated for increased representation of women in cardiovascular research studies for nearly two decades.
Go Red for Women's Research Goes Red empowers women to contribute to health research. The initiative has built a community of women scientists, researchers, and medical and health professionals to further raise awareness around women's heart health by closing gender disparity gaps in research and clinical trials.
In light of the COVID-19 pandemic, Research Goes Red expanded their reach and impact through a COVID-19 survey. This survey assesses the top concerns women have related to the health, social, economic, and emotional impact COVID-19 has had on their lives.
Bugiardini, R., et al. (2020) Prior Beta-Blocker Therapy for Hypertension and Sex-Based Differences in Heart Failure Among Patients With Incident Coronary Heart Disease. Hypertension: Journal of the American Heart Association. doi.org/10.1161/HYPERTENSIONAHA.120.15323.